Chemistry · Organic chemistry: basic principles and techniques · chapter 8 of 9

Class 11 Chemistry Chapter 8: Organic Chemistry – Some Basic Principles and Techniques case study question with answers

One case-based question of the kind CBSE-pattern school exams ask: a passage, then 3 parts worth 4 marks in all, with the answer and the marking scheme for each. Written from the NCERT chapter.

Case study · 4 marks
Meera spots a leaf extract and two pure compounds, P and Q, side by side on a silica gel TLC plate, 2 cm above its lower edge, and places the plate in a closed jar containing the eluant. When she removes it, the solvent front is 8.0 cm above the base line. The extract shows two spots, at 2.0 cm and 5.6 cm above the base line; P has run to 5.6 cm and Q to 2.0 cm. P is yellow and is seen at once. Q is colourless and appears as a brown spot only after the plate is kept in a covered jar with a few iodine crystals.
Part 1 · 1 mark
The Rf value of P is
Show answer

Answer: (b) 0.70

Rf = 5.6/8.0 = 0.70. 1.43 inverts the ratio; 0.25 is Q's value; 0.56 divides by 10 instead of 8.0.

Part 2 · 1 mark
Which statement about the plate is correct?
Show answer

Answer: (c) Q is adsorbed more strongly than P, and the extract contains both P and Q

Q moves less, so it is held more strongly by the silica gel; the extract's two spots match P and Q in height.

Part 3 · 2 marks
Why did Q become visible in the iodine jar? Name one other way in which the spot of a colourless compound can be located on a TLC plate.
Answer and marking scheme

Q adsorbs iodine vapour, so its spot shows up brown. A colourless compound that fluoresces can be seen under ultraviolet light (or a suitable reagent can be sprayed on the plate).

  • Q adsorbs iodine, giving a brown spot (1)
  • UV light for fluorescent compounds, or a spray reagent (1)
Or
Suppose Q is an amino acid. How could its spot be revealed without iodine? Explain, in terms of adsorption, why Q's Rf is lower than P's.
Answer and marking scheme

Amino acids are detected by spraying the plate with ninhydrin solution. Q is adsorbed more strongly on the silica gel than P, so it is held back and moves a smaller distance with the eluant, giving a lower Rf.

  • spray with ninhydrin solution (1)
  • stronger adsorption, smaller distance, lower Rf (1)
Take the free Class 11 Chemistry testSee the Class 11 flashcards

← Chapter 7: Redox ReactionsChapter 9: Hydrocarbons →